Regional HR Leaders Discuss the Impact of Distance on Performance in Regional HR Teams
- Date:
- 9 September 2009
The Chapman Consulting Group today hosted an HR roundtable discussion for 16 select HR Heads. Regional HR Leaders from high-profile multinationals in the Financial Services, Hospitality, Shipping, Biotech, Education, Logistics and Pharmaceutical sectors met over lunch at the Singapore Cricket Club to discuss the topic of "What Regional HR Leaders Need to Know about the Impact of Distance on Performance". The discussion was led by James Eyring, Chief Operating Officer of Organisation Solutions, a leading global Organisation and Leadership Development consulting firm headquartered in Asia.
The Performance of Dispersed Teams Versus Co-located Teams
Eyring discussed research that clearly showed that distance can reduce team performance when compared to teams where all members are based in the same location. However, this research also shows that teams separated by distance, time and culture can perform just as well as if not better than collocated teams, so long as they implement the right tools and processes.
A number of distance factors impact performance. For example, if just one team member is based in a different location to the rest, performance levels of the team are generally unaffected, as the 'core' members tend to go out of their way to include the one exceptional 'lone' member. However in a situation where 70% of a team is in one location and 30% is in another, the smaller team can easily start to feel as though decisions favour the larger team, allowing for personal and professional conflicts to arise. One lunch attendee recounted a situation in their company that illustrated this, when the Asia regional team and the global team had held a teleconference to make a decision on an important issue. The group came to a conclusion in the call, however the Asia team woke up the next morning to find an email from the global team explaining that they'd later agreed on a completely different solution. It didn't take long before this approach to long-distance management had a detrimental effect on the performance of the team.
In breaking down the particular challenges of dispersed team management, a number of issues emerged. Of lower importance were such challenges as managing across time-zones, the difficulty to coach and mentor team members, and the necessity of structures and processes to ensure smooth running. Of medium importance was the diversity of problems across disparate markets, the difficulties in physically getting things done, and the complexity of communicating effectively. However the number one issue in long-distance management was the challenge of building trust between team members. Participants of the lunch agreed that without a foundation of trust between their HR team, it is impossible to manage a cohesive and performance-led culture within the group. So how can this trust be built?



